Modern Classrooms Project

View Original

Grade Smarter, Not Harder

There are many reasons why you became a teacher, but I'd guess that "grading stacks of papers" was not high among them.  I'd also guess that, with all the other work a Modern Classroom entails -- recording videos, updating a progress tracker, maintaining your LMS, etc. -- reviewing an endless stream of assignments and mastery checks is not appealing.

It's hard for us to say what the "right" grading policy is: every school and district has its own policies, and every educator has a different philosophy when it comes to grades.  Follow your school's guidance -- and your own conscience -- before you listen to me!  But, as you consider what exactly you'll grade next year, within those prescribed guidelines, here are a few principles that I always tried to keep in mind:
 

★ Grades should be a snapshot of understanding.  I never saw a student's grade as a complete record of that student's knowledge or ability.  Rather, the grade was a quick indicator of the level of understanding that student has shown to date.  For that reason, I didn't feel the need to grade every assignment.  I graded all mastery checks -- which demonstrate understanding -- and treated other classwork as practice for those mastery checks.  This helped both me and my students prioritize, and ensured that students' grades truly reflected their understanding.

★ Grades should be temporary.  Understanding develops over time, and grades should as well.  I let students retake mastery checks whenever they wanted, and gave full credit once they really got it.  This at times created extra work for me -- some students needed to reassess a few times -- but kept the focus on understanding, and felt more equitable for students who often missed class.  And believe me, my students didn't relish those retakes any more than I did!  Over time, they learned to prepare (using ungraded practice) to succeed the first or second time around.

★ Grades are only one way to motivate students.  Don't get me wrong -- I relied heavily on grades as a motivator for my students.  But I also tried to emphasize other reasons for working hard and getting ahead: interesting aspire-to-do assignments, the ability to help classmates, and the pride that comes from learning.  I also found that emails home, which emphasized students' positive attitudes and characteristics (in addition to grades) went a long way.
 

Will my own grading practices work for you?  Maybe, or may not!  But I hope these ideas will help you decide how you can grade efficiently and effectively in your own Modern Classroom.

Curious how some of our Expert Mentors grade?  Explore Mentors' Grading Policies!